On this page
Embedded Value Insurance: Life Insurer Hidden Worth
The embedded value insurance metric estimates the economic worth of a life insurer to its shareholders, equal to net asset value plus the present value of profits expected from policies already on the books. It is the most common supplementary disclosure for European life insurers and a key bridge between accounting earnings and underlying value.
Key Takeaways
- Embedded value equals free surplus plus required capital plus present value of in-force covered business profits.
- The CFO Forum published European Embedded Value principles in 2004 and Market Consistent EV principles in 2008.
- MCEV uses market-consistent discount rates while EEV allows top-down or bottom-up risk discount rate approaches.
- Investors use the EV per share as a floor valuation reference for life insurers in low-growth markets.
Key Takeaways
- Embedded value equals free surplus plus required capital plus present value of in-force covered business profits.
- The CFO Forum published European Embedded Value principles in 2004 and Market Consistent EV principles in 2008.
- MCEV uses market-consistent discount rates while EEV allows top-down or bottom-up risk discount rate approaches.
- Investors use the EV per share as a floor valuation reference for life insurers in low-growth markets.
What It Is
The embedded value insurance metric, defined by the CFO Forum and updated in 2016, is a shareholder-value measure tailored to long-duration life and savings business. GAAP and IFRS accounting recognize life insurance profits gradually over time, which understates the economic value of a new policy at sale. Embedded value reverses that lag by showing the entire shareholder economic interest at the valuation date.
Two principal versions exist in current use. European Embedded Value, or EEV, was published by the CFO Forum in 2004. Market Consistent Embedded Value, or MCEV, was published in 2008 and refined in 2016 with a tighter alignment to market reference assumptions and to Solvency II valuation methods.
The Intuition
A life insurer typically pays large acquisition costs in year one, then collects level premiums and earns small spreads over many decades. Statutory and GAAP accounting recover the acquisition cost over time, so reported earnings are low or negative when business is growing fast, even when the new policies are profitable.
Embedded value strips out that timing distortion. It treats the in-force book as a long-dated bond and discounts the expected future shareholder cash flows to a single number. A growing embedded value with a positive value of new business signals the company is creating economic value, even if accounting earnings look modest.
How It Works
The MCEV framework defines three components.
MCEV = Free surplus
+ Required capital
+ Value of in-force covered business (VIF)
Free surplus is shareholder capital not needed to support the in-force book. Required capital is the capital that local regulators or the insurer's internal model require behind the existing policies, typically anchored at the Solvency II SCR for European groups.
VIF, the most analytical piece, is built from the present value of future profits with explicit adjustments.
VIF = PVFP
- Time value of financial options and guarantees (TVFOG)
- Frictional cost of required capital (FCRC)
- Cost of residual non-hedgeable risk (CRNHR)
PVFP is the projected after-tax statutory profit from the existing block, discounted at a market-consistent rate. The three deductions reflect the cost of guarantees the insurer has sold, the cost of locking up capital, and the cost of risks that cannot be hedged in financial markets.
EEV is structurally similar but allows a top-down risk-discount-rate approach, which can produce different numbers when interest rates and equity risk premia diverge.
Worked Example
A European life insurer reports the following MCEV roll-forward.
Opening MCEV: 4,500 million euros
Free surplus: 800
Required capital: 1,200
Value of in-force: 2,500
Operating EV earnings:
Expected return on opening EV: +180
Value of new business: +250
Operating variances: +30
----
+460
Economic variances (rates): -120
Capital movements (dividends): -150
Other: -10
Closing MCEV: 4,680 million euros
Free surplus: 720
Required capital: 1,260
Value of in-force: 2,700
The 250 million of value of new business is the most important line. It tells investors the period's sales added economic value at the current price and assumption set, on top of the 180 million unwinding of the existing book at the expected return.
Common Mistakes
- Comparing EEV and MCEV directly. Different risk discount rate methods and different treatment of guarantees can move embedded value by 10% or more.
- Treating embedded value as cash. EV includes the present value of future profits that may take 30 years to emerge. It is not distributable, only the free surplus piece is.
- Ignoring economic variances. Falling rates increase liability values and can cut EV sharply, even when sales and operating performance are good.
- Using EV multiples blindly. A price to embedded value of 1.0 looks like fair value but depends entirely on the assumptions inside the EV calculation. Sensitivities are essential.
- Forgetting non-covered business. Holding company costs, asset management subsidiaries, and non-life operations sit outside the covered business and need to be added separately for group valuation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is embedded value insurance in simple terms? It is a single number for the economic worth of a life insurer, equal to its net assets plus the present value of future profits from policies already sold. It is published as a supplement to standard accounting reports.
How does embedded value affect investment decisions? Equity analysts use price to embedded value multiples to compare European life insurers, and growth in EV per share is one of the cleanest available measures of long-run shareholder value creation. Persistent EV declines warn of pricing or assumption stress.
What is a real-world example of embedded value? Major European life groups such as Allianz, Aviva, and Generali publish MCEV or equivalent supplementary statements annually, including sensitivity tables to interest rates, equity markets, and lapse assumptions.
How can investors use embedded value effectively? Track EV per share growth, watch the value of new business as a forward indicator, and read sensitivity tables to see how a 100 basis point rate shock would change the number.
How is embedded value different from book value? Book value is the accounting net worth on the balance sheet, while embedded value adds the present value of future profits from the in-force policy book on top of that net worth.
Sources
- CFO Forum, MCEV Principles and Guidance, April 2016. https://cfoforum.eu/mediaitem/3b8d66a9-7752-497e-8f71-2d0804ae9e73/CFO-Forum_MCEV_Principles_and_Guidance_April_2016.pdf
- CFO Forum, European Embedded Value Principles, April 2016. https://cfoforum.eu/mediaitem/587a904d-c334-4de7-b2ca-c09dc2304814/CFO-Forum_EEV_Principles_and_Guidance_April_2016.pdf
- American Academy of Actuaries, MCEV Practice Note. https://www.actuary.org/files/MCEV%20Practice%20Note%20Final%20WEB%20031611.4.pdf/MCEV%20Practice%20Note%20Final%20WEB%20031611.4.pdf
- Society of Actuaries, Embedded Value: Practice and Theory (Frasca and LaSorella). https://www.soa.org/globalassets/assets/library/journals/actuarial-practice-forum/2009/march/apf-2009-03-frasca-lasorella.pdf
Disclaimer
This article is educational content only and is not financial advice. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security. Consult a licensed advisor before making investment decisions.